By Francis Orina
The High Court in Nyamira has acquitted four people charged with the murder of a US-based couple at Egetugi Village in Nyamira County about three years ago.
Nyamira Resident Judge Justice Thripsisa Cherere ordered the immediate release of Ezekiel Mogeni Migiro, Peris Ondara, a former teacher at Tala Primary School in Machakos County, her brother Denis Ondara Clement, and their alleged accomplice, Peter Njoroge Kirika.
Also Read
In her judgment, Justice Cherere found that the prosecution had failed to present sufficient evidence linking the four accused persons to the murders.
The judge said investigators and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) had not established the suspects’ involvement in the killings, particularly under the doctrine of common intention.
Quoting Section 21 of the Penal Code, Justice Cherere said the prosecution had failed to demonstrate that the accused shared a common intention to kill Edward and Grace Morema or that the murders were committed in furtherance of a common unlawful purpose.
“Having considered the evidence against the requirements of Section 21 of the Penal Code, this Court finds that the prosecution did not establish that the four accused persons shared a common intention to murder Edward and Grace, or that the murders were committed in furtherance of a common unlawful purpose. The charge of murder against each accused person therefore cannot be sustained on the basis of common intention,” Justice Cherere said.
The prosecution called 16 witnesses during the trial, including a househelp and a farmhand who worked at the home of the deceased couple.
The court agreed with the prosecution that Edward and Grace were killed in a brutal manner and that their attackers had acted with malice aforethought.
Their bodies were discovered in the garage of their single-storey house, with their hands and feet bound with binding wires and their mouths gagged with pieces of cloth. They had sustained multiple injuries to different parts of their bodies, although investigators established that neither had suffered gunshot wounds.

The judge also found that the prosecution had failed to establish a connection between a succession dispute involving the extended family of the late Morema and the murders.
The financial transactions presented as a key part of the prosecution’s case also failed to establish the accused persons’ involvement in the killings.
Transaction records showed that Sh62,000 had been transferred from the accounts of Edward and Grace to telephone number 0711488636, while Sh35,500 was subsequently withdrawn from a Co-operative Bank ATM at 11.37pm.
However, the court noted that the records did not establish who physically possessed or operated the mobile phone when the transactions were made.
The prosecution also presented evidence that the person who withdrew the money was wearing a cap and face mask, making identification through CCTV footage difficult.
The four accused persons had spent approximately three and a half years in custody before their acquittal.





