Editor's Review

The proposal has prompted Telkom Kenya to ask lawmakers to protect existing unlimited and speed-based packages, warning that making metered billing compulsory could disrupt the fixed broadband market and limit consumer choice.

By GPC Reporter

For families paying a fixed monthly fee for home internet, the appeal of an unlimited package is simple: they can work, study, stream videos and browse without constantly worrying about running out of data.

But that convenience could come under scrutiny if Parliament adopts proposed changes requiring internet service providers to bill customers according to the amount of data they consume.

The proposal has prompted Telkom Kenya to ask lawmakers to protect existing unlimited and speed-based packages, warning that making metered billing compulsory could disrupt the fixed broadband market and limit consumer choice.

Appearing before the National Assembly Committee on Communication, Information and Innovation on Tuesday, Telkom Chief Executive Officer Mugo Kibati argued that consumers should continue choosing how they pay for internet services.

He cautioned that regulations intended to protect customers could have unintended consequences for a sector that is still expanding.

“Sometimes you can go overboard in trying to protect consumers that you actually kill a nascent, growing sector,” Kibati warned.

The debate centres on the Kenya Information and Communications (Amendment) Bill, 2025, sponsored by Aldai MP Marianne Kitany.

The proposed law seeks to introduce mandatory metered internet billing, requiring providers to monitor individual customers’ data consumption, assign subscribers unique meter numbers and issue bills based on actual usage.

Internet providers would also be required to submit information about their billing systems, including subscriber meter numbers, to the Communications Authority of Kenya (CA) at least once every financial year.

The intention is to ensure customers pay for the services they actually consume and are protected from exploitation through unclear or unfair billing practices.

However, Telkom believes the same objective can be achieved without forcing every provider to adopt a single billing model.

Mugo Kibati.

Telkom wants customers to retain choice

Kibati told the committee that mobile internet accounts for about 96 per cent of data subscriptions in Kenya and is already billed according to consumption.

Fixed broadband accounts for the remaining four per cent, but subscriptions in the segment are growing by more than 30 per cent annually, according to the company.

Telkom argued that imposing additional metering requirements on fixed broadband could place unnecessary obligations on providers and affect a market whose growth depends partly on the availability of different packages.

Instead, the company wants providers to clearly disclose their billing models, charges and fair usage policies before customers sign up.

It has also proposed that subscribers should be able to access information about their data consumption free of charge, request itemised bills and use effective mechanisms to challenge disputed charges.

The company further suggested independent audits of billing accuracy where necessary, while recommending that the regulator receive aggregated subscriber information rather than individual customer records.

It also wants at least 18 months to comply with any new requirements introduced under the proposed law.

Regulator’s concerns

Telkom is not alone in questioning whether compulsory usage-based billing is the best way to protect internet consumers.

The Communications Authority, in submissions to the same committee on November 3, cautioned against making consumption-based billing mandatory across the sector.

The regulator argued that such a system could make household internet expenditure less predictable, particularly for families, students and small businesses that depend on stable monthly budgets.

It proposed alternative safeguards, including real-time data usage dashboards and alerts when customers reach 50, 80 and 100 per cent of their consumption limits.

The CA also recommended optional spending caps to help subscribers control their bills, alongside clearer billing information, independent verification of metering systems and affordable broadband packages for low-income consumers.

Telkom additionally warned that requiring persistent subscriber identifiers and annual reporting could expose sensitive personal information if adequate safeguards were not put in place under the Data Protection Act.

Committee chairman John Kiarie welcomed the company’s submissions, saying Parliament would be disadvantaged if it made laws affecting the telecommunications industry without consulting the operators.

There is concern whether households and businesses will retain the freedom to choose packages that allow them to plan their monthly expenses.

The proposed amendments are still under parliamentary consideration and have not become law.