By Nyang’au Araka
The Salaries and Remuneration Commission (SRC) will appeal a High Court ruling that limited its authority over judges’ benefits and allowances.
The decision sets up a constitutional dispute over the respective mandates of the SRC and the Judicial Service Commission (JSC).
Also Read
The commission said this week that it would challenge the judgment in a petition filed by Marion Joy Onchagwa, which held that SRC’s mandate in the Judiciary was limited to setting and reviewing remuneration, while other benefits and conditions of service fell under the JSC.
In the judgment delivered on October 23, 2026, Lady Justice R. E. Aburili ruled that SRC had exceeded its constitutional mandate by making decisions on the welfare of judges, judicial officers and judicial staff beyond remuneration.
The court held that medical cover, Daily Subsistence Allowance (DSA) and Special Judicial Duty Allowance were not remuneration and therefore fell within the JSC’s mandate.
It also found that SRC had violated Article 160(4) of the Constitution by varying judges’ medical cover and DSA to their disadvantage. The provision protects judges against reductions in their remuneration and benefits.
The dispute arose from an SRC letter dated October 13, 2023, which reduced optical and dental cover from KSh200,000 to KSh75,000 each and DSA from KSh25,000 to KSh18,000.
The court quashed the relevant portions of the letter relating to benefits other than remuneration, declaring that SRC had encroached on the JSC’s constitutional functions and interfered with judicial independence.
However, the court dismissed complaints concerning transport allowance and the car loan facility, ruling that the petitioner had not provided sufficient evidence to support the claims.
In announcing its intention to appeal, SRC argued that Article 230(4) of the Constitution gives it the mandate to set and regularly review the remuneration and benefits of all State officers.
The commission maintained that allowances and benefits attached to a State office fall within its mandate, regardless of whether they are also classified as conditions of service.
“A benefit that facilitates official duty is still part of the total compensation of a State officer and is still paid from public funds,” SRC said.
The commission said the ruling raised a constitutional question of national importance, warning that excluding the Judiciary from its standard framework for determining allowances could undermine consistency across the public service.

SRC said it had established standard DSA rates based on geographical clusters and job grades to address disparities in the public service.
It cautioned that allowing other government institutions to independently determine their allowances and benefits could result in divergent rates for comparable work, increased demands for parity and further litigation.
“The result would be divergent rates for comparable work, parity claims, upward pressure on allowances and a fresh wave of litigation that may produce a fragmented body of law,” the commission said.
The judgment interpreted Article 230(4) alongside Article 172(1)(b)(i), which assigns the JSC responsibility for reviewing and making recommendations on the conditions of service of judges and judicial officers, other than their remuneration.
The court concluded that the two constitutional commissions had distinct responsibilities, with SRC handling remuneration and the JSC overseeing other conditions of service and benefits within the Judiciary.
SRC said it would continue defending its constitutional mandate, arguing that its role was to ensure public sector remuneration and benefits were fair, equitable, transparent and fiscally sustainable.
“The people of Kenya entrusted SRC with the mandate of ensuring the remuneration and benefits for all State and public officers are determined fairly,” the commission said.





